skip to primary navigationskip to content

Magna Moralia (Mayweek and Craven seminar 2010)

All sessions in room 1.11, Faculty of Classics.

The seminar is open to anyone resident in Cambridge who is prepared to attend for the full week. Visitors from outside Cambridge should check with David Sedley (dns1@cam.ac.uk), because space is limited.

(1) Monday May 24th, 10:30 AM - 12:30 PM. David Sedley.

-- A I-IV (1181a24-1185a39: the nature of ethics; virtue; doxographical survey; the nature of goodness; eudaimonia)

(2) Monday May 24th, 4:00 PM - 6:00 PM. Sarah Broadie.

-- A V-XVI (1185b1-1188b38: the soul; defect and excess; pleasure and pain; habituation; mean states and the extremes; what is up to us?  the (in)voluntary)

(3) Tuesday May 25th, 10:30 AM - 12:30 PM. Giles Pearson.

-- A XVII-XXVI (1189a1-1192b17: choice; error; the telos; courage; temperance; gentleness; liberality; greatness of soul; magnificence)

(4) Tuesday May 25th, 4:00 PM - 6:00 PM. James Warren.

-- A XXVII-XXXIII (1192b18-1196b3: righteous indignation; dignity; modesty; urbanity; friendship; sincerity; justice: (i) its kinds; (ii) proportionality; (iii) domestic ‘justice’? (iv) political justice; (v) conventional and natural justice; (vi) conditions for (un)just action; (vii) suffering injustice voluntarily?)

(5) Wednesday May 26th, 10:30 AM - 12:30 PM. Richard McKirahan.

A XXXIV-B III (1196b4-1200a34: orthos logos; intellectual faculties and virtues; ‘natural’ virtue; phronesis; equity; discrimination; euboulia; is equal distribution characteristic of the just? does the unjust have phronesis? can one injure a bad person? can the virtues conflict? can one have too much virtue?)

(6) Wednesday May 26th, 4:00 PM - 6:00 PM. Nick Denyer.

B IV-VI (1200a35-1204a18: self-control and incontinence; bestiality; pace Socrates, incontinence exists; puzzles concerning self-control; analysis of incontinence)

(7) Thursday May 27th, 10:30 AM - 12:30 PM. Stephen White.

B VII-VIII (1204a19-1207b18: pleasure; arguments against its goodness; replies to these arguments; can bad logos overcome good pathe? good fortune)

(8) Thursday May 27th, 4:00 PM - 6:00 PM. Malcolm Schofield.

B IX-XI (1207b19-1210b32: kalokagathia; orthos logos again; pathe; analysis of friendship)

(9) Friday May 28th, 10:30 AM - 12:30 PM. Christopher Rowe.

B XI-XVII (1210b33-1213b30: friendship continued)

(10) Friday May 28th, 4:00 PM - 6:00 PM. Robert Wardy.

Retrospect.

Friday evening: party for all participants


STARTER BIBLIOGRAPHY

Text

Aristotelis Quae Feruntur Magna Moralia, ed. Franz Susemihl, Teubner, 1883 (free download available at: www.archive.org/details/aristotelisquae01susegoog)

Commentary

Aristoteles Magna Moralia, übersetzt und kommentiert von Franz Dirlmeier (Berlin, 1983) (originally published in 1958 - the first major modern defence of authenticity)

H. Bonitz, Observationes criticae in Aristotelis quae feruntur Magna Moralia et Ethica Eudemia ( Berlin 1844)

Secondary literature

John Cooper, ‘The Magna Moralia and Aristotle’s moral philosophy’, in his Reason and Emotion (Princeton, 1999), pp.195-211 (the second major modern defence of authenticity)

Christopher Rowe, ‘A reply to John Cooper on the Magna Moralia’, AJP 96 (1975): 160-72 (defending the orthodox view that the MM is post-Aristotelian)

RSS Feed Latest news

Museum and Collections Assistant

Jan 25, 2019

Further particulars and details of how to apply for this part-time post are available online. See web link for further information.

J. Paul Getty Medal

Jan 25, 2019

The Faculty is delighted to report that Mary Beard has been named as one of this year's recipients of the J. Paul Getty Medal. See weblink for further information.

University Lectureship in Classics (Ancient Philosophy)

Jan 24, 2019

Further particulars and details of how to apply for this established post are now available on line. Closing date: 6 March 2019.

150th Anniversary of the Society for Classical Studies

Jan 10, 2019

Mary Beard's public lecture at the Society for Classical Studies, at the annual meeting in San Diego on January 5th 2019, is now available to view online. See here for more details.

View all news